California: Supreme Court Upholds Authority Of Cities To Prohibit Medical Marijuana Facilities

Thursday, 09 May 2013

California: Supreme Court Upholds Authority Of Cities To Prohibit Medical Marijuana FacilitiesSan Francisco, CA: The California Supreme Court ruled Monday that municipalities possess the legal authority to prohibit the establishment of medical cannabis dispensaries.

The unanimous ruling upheld a 4th District Court of Appeals opinion (City of Riverside v. Inland Empire Patients' Health and Wellness Center, Inc.) which held that local zoning measures banning the establishment of brick-and-mortar facilities that engage in the distribution of cannabis to state-authorized persons are not preempted by state law. Other lower courts had ruled against such local bans, arguing that cities can't use zoning laws to bar activity legal under state law.

It is estimated that some 200 California cities presently impose moratoriums on medicinal cannabis facilities. At least 50 municipalities have enacted local regulations licensing dispensaries.

Opined the Court: "Nothing in the CUA (the California Compassionate Use Act aka Proposition 215) or the MMP (the Medical Marijuana Program Act) expressly or impliedly limits the inherent authority of a local jurisdiction, by its own ordinances, to regulate the use of its land, including the authority to provide that facilities for the distribution of medical marijuana will not be permitted to operate within its borders."

Although language included in Proposition 215 explicitly calls for the state government "to implement a plan for the safe and affordable distribution of marijuana to all patients in medical need of marijuana," to date, lawmakers have failed to enact any specific statewide regulations regarding the plant's retail distribution to authorized patients.

Commenting on the ruling, California NORML Coordinator Dale Gieringer said, "The court essentially affirmed the status quo. Local governments may choose to allow or limit dispensaries as they please. The unfortunate result of this decision is to leave many needy patients without legal access to medical marijuana in their communities, thereby promoting illegal black market suppliers. It is time for the state and federal governments to step up to the plate and fulfill the mandate of Prop 215 to implement a system of 'safe and affordable' access for all patients in medical need."

Legislation is presently pending in both the California Assembly (AB 473) and Senate (SB 439) to impose statewide regulations governing the dispensing of marijuana produced for medical purposes.

Full text of the California Supreme Court's opinion is available online at: http://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/S198638.PDF.