Big Brouhaha in DC as Legalization is Phased-In

Legalization in DCThe new marijuana laws recently approved by the voters of the District of Columbia (Initiative 71) by nearly 70 percent took effect last week, following a 30-day period in which the US Congress had the opportunity to override the provision, but our opponents did not have the votes.

So it is now perfectly legal in the District of Columbia to possess up to two ounces of marijuana; to cultivate up to six plants in the home, not more than three of which may be flowering; and to give away, but not sell, up to one ounce of marijuana to someone at least 21 years of age. It is one of the better decriminalization laws in the country, a welcome half-way step that is now law in 17 states as well as the District.

I say it is a half-way step, because while it legalizes the possession and use of marijuana by adults, it does not establish a legal, regulated market, such as those currently operating in Colorado and Washington, and soon to be up and running in Oregon and Alaska. (Voter initiatives in DC may not require the expenditure of city funds, so that was not an option). In DC, marijuana smokers will either have to cultivate their own marijuana in their home, or continue to buy their marijuana on the black market, with no quality controls to protect them from contaminants such as molds or pesticides, and no way to evaluate the strength of the product.

Decriminalization is obviously a giant step forward for any jurisdiction, as it ends the practice of treating marijuana smokers as criminals. Although in DC the elected City Council has already reduced the penalty for possession of up to one ounce of marijuana to a civil offense, punishable by a fine of $25, so the latest change will not be dramatic, and the changes will largely go unnoticed by the general public. Nonetheless, it is good to get rid of the fine altogether and finally make marijuana possession and cultivation legal.

Perhaps most significant, now that possession of two ounces of marijuana is legal in the District, the smell of marijuana, traditionally used by the police as legal justification to search the passenger compartment of a car without the need to obtain a search warrant, no longer provides probable cause for a search. It is impossible for the police to tell whether the marijuana they are smelling is more or less than the two ounce limit, so this much-abused police practice now must stop.

Similarly, the smell of marijuana when the police come to someone’s home has traditionally been used by the police as probable cause to obtain a search warrant for someone’s home; that common, abusive practice must now also end. So the new laws in the District will have the positive result of protecting our right to privacy and reinforcing our 4th Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures.

Interestingly, Mayor Muriel Bowser and a majority of the DC City Council members were poised to develop and approve a set of regulations to license growers and dispensaries in the District, until the drug warriors in Congress used the budget bill approved at the end of the last Congress to preclude the District from spending any of its money to legalize marijuana. Some on the council have long supported more progressive marijuana laws, while others resent the interference of Congress in the local affairs in the District, which enjoys a limited form of “home rule.”

The anti-pot zealots in Congress, led by Rep. Andy Harris (R-MD), had thought their budget amendment would also stop the provisions of Initiative 71 from being implemented, but the mayor and City Council Chair Phil Mendelson and the new DC Attorney General all took the position that the initiative was “self-enacting” and required no expenditure of funds by the District, and they are treating the Congressional budget amendment as having no effect on the initiative, although they acknowledge it would block the Council from going further to regulate the market.

When the anti-marijuana ideologues in Congress saw that the elected leadership in the District were going to enforce the language of the new initiative, they publicly threatened to have the mayor and other city officials arrested! To the everlasting credit of Mayor Bowser, Council Chair Phil Mendelson and Police Chief Cathy Lanier, they held a joint press conference explaining what is and is not allowed by the new laws (no public smoking; no selling; no outdoor cultivation; and no possession on federal lands, which comprise roughly 29 percent of the District’s total land area), and announcing the new laws would take effect at 12:01am on Thursday, Feb. 26th.

It was wonderful to see a united defense of the right of the voters in the District of Columbia to determine their own marijuana policy, free from Congressional interference.

This situation may yet end up being resolved by the courts, but for the moment, the good guys are winning. As an aside, the mayor has now called for the City Council to adopt new legislation making it clear that Amsterdam-style “cannabis clubs” will not be tolerated in DC; a sop, I suppose, to the other side. We will try to stop the ban from being enacted. Smoking marijuana is a social activity, and there is no reason to limit marijuana smoking only to a private home. Hopefully we can find some middle ground that will permit smokers to exercise their new right in other private areas. This issue too may end up in the courts.

New Alaska Penalties Also Took Effect

The new legalization law recently approved by the voters in Alaska (Measure 2) calls for the establishment of licensed growers and sellers by the end of the year, but there too the parts of the new law eliminating all penalties for possession of up to one ounce of marijuana, and for cultivating up to six plants in the home, took effect last week. Once again, little will change initially for smokers in Alaska, since they have enjoyed protection from arrest or prosecution for possessing personal use amounts of marijuana in the home since 1978, because of a state Supreme Court decision, Ravin v State, finding such conduct protected by the right to privacy provisions in the state constitution.

But again, as in DC, the police will no longer be able to use the mere smell of marijuana as probable cause to search a vehicle, so the legal significance of the new law is enormous.

Oregon Law to Take Effect in Mid-Year

The new penalties approved by the voters in Oregon (Measure 91) will take effect on July 1, although the state has until Jan. 1, 2016 to implement the provisions regulating the cultivation and sale of marijuana. As of July 1, Oregonians will be legally permitted to possess up to one ounce of marijuana in public and up to eight ounces of marijuana in the home (and one pound of solid edibiles, 72-ounces of infused liquid, and one ounce of extracts), along with the right to grow up to four plants per household.

Until that time, possession of an ounce or less remains a non-criminal violation, carrying a fine-only, with no possibility of jail.

#     #     #

This column was originally published on

25 thoughts

  1. it may be a foot in the door but this is not “legalization”.
    on its own merits the plant should be treated like coffee or tea- no tax, no regulate!
    3 plants in flower and whatever ounces is still causeless tyrannical b.s.

  2. This is a great thing for this country,,, we are slowly getting our freedom back in order,,, people from now on we must vote only for officials in our country that are for the people// and not for there back pockets … if the people in this great country would wake up we can have the best medicine all natural with no side effects …just look at …phoenix tears rick simpsons cancer cure .com ////////// read the testimonials it will blow your mind ,,,at the good that cannabis can do for our people ,,,one more thing before i go ,,,you have to go to article dea warns of stoned rabbits if utah passes medical mj….you will laugh your a$$ off ,,,,god bless those poor rabbits and america ???

  3. The anti-pot zealots in Congress, led by Rep. Andy Harris (R-MD) would be well advised to move to another country where the people think the way they do; like Iran! These so-called leaders are about as Un-American as your average terrorist. They don’t care about freedom of even choosing to do right instead of wrong. They seem to care only about their personal predjudicial agenda. May they all ultimately get what they deserve; and in my opinion that would be the jail/prison time they advocate for us! Screw Them!

  4. Upholding 4th Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures gives power back to us where it belongs. Privacy is freedom. Nothing compares to the feeling that freedom brings to the soul. Washington DC has the kind of leadership that understands this issue. Brave leadership indeed.

  5. One major factor here is this decriminalization of recreational marijuana has occurred on the East coast, the wasteland of pot legalization. Best prez and best mayor ever!

  6. As we speak minds are melding to find reasons to keep arresting. I call it the Texas formula. Abortions are legal in Texas but most of the clinics have been regulated out of business. Unreasonable demands that are almost imposable to implement. Florida is a state that will choke progress. regulate the content to worthless then arrest the black market people. The BILLY BOB STATES VERSION OF LEGALIZATION MIGHT ACTUALLY MAKE MORE ARREST POSSIBLE. TAX EVADERS ECT.. Right now they are proposing that the growers of medical marijuana plants will have had to have been in the greenery business in Florida for over 30 years to qualify for a license. Just because you know how to grow hedges does not equal a good weed grower. They will be selling junk weed or less following the state mandate and continue to arrest. DECRIMINALIZATION IS BEST IN THE JERK WATER STATES. If not Charlottes Web will be al they will make available.

  7. Yeah, Keith is right, many reasons why this D.C. legalization is going to end up in court. The contradictions, hypocrisies and conflicts this law exposes in our federal marijuana policy is just begging for law suits. And we’re still waiting for Judge Mueller’s verdict over the Constitutionality of marijuana’s scheduling this month!

    Think about it; a Congressman can now take a lunch break and not worry about smelling like marijuana when stepping out of a vehicle in D.C. before returning to Federal property to vote on marijuana laws. How cool is that?

    Nonetheless, while citizens of D.C. can grow their own to consume safe marijuana out of the black market, a case worker from the Department of Health and Human Services can still take custody of one’s children for growing marijuana in their own home with their own children. That has had my head shaking from the beginning with the current state of D.C. Marijuana Policy, and this is just one example of an event that will eventually end up in court as we continue to exercise our right to privacy, life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

  8. Though this is just the first step, it IS a first step. I would gladly take this, as incomplete as it is, over the criminalization that still exists in my state of NM. So, congrats to the smokers and advocates in DC; you’ve cleared at least one hurdle.

  9. Just read an interesting article that doesn’t bode well for prohibitionists.

    According to the Pew Research Center, a majority, 63%, of GOP millennials (born between ’81 and ’96), support MJ legalization. Added to the strong support, 77%, of Dem millennials, this means the young generations coming up heavily support legalization. If that doesn’t send sweat beads running down the temples of the prohibitionist wing of the GOP, which is undoubtedly the majority of them, nothing will.

    The only age demographics who still favor prohibition of course are the famed Silent Majority (born 1928-1945), with only 17% of old GOPers supporting legalization and 44% of aged Dems.

    After 1945 (those born after that year), every major demographic of Dems supports legalization, 66% of Boomers and 61% of Gen-X. The majority of Repubs in those same age demos of course favor prohibition; but as their advancement for legalization, from 38% (Boomers) to 47% (Gen-Xers) show, even they are slowly, painfully slowly, advancing toward enlightenment.

    You know the leaders of the GOP are noticing this too, the current theatrics in DC notwithstanding.

    I hope the Dem prohibitionists are noticing this too.

  10. If Harris and the prohibitionists succeed in jailing DC leaders, let’s hope the 70+ percent of DC residents that approved the new marijuana laws take to the streets in protest.

    Never forget AJ Anslinger’s famous words, ‘When a darkie smokes marijuana, he thinks he’s just as good as a white man!”

  11. Is there any way to speed things up in DC? Driving to Colorado from the East Coast is just not possible. No way. No how. It would be nice if the states along the route to and from Colorado and those still prohibitionist states neighboring on other recreational cannabis states would either decriminalize or otherwise just not do the police paperwork for amounts under a certain number of grams. So you could bring back 5 grams with you or whatever amount without worry, basically. Back to the question is there any way to speed things up in DC by getting some dirt on Chaffetz,Harris or these other prohibitionist yoyos You got that I-95 corridor, and I want to make sure the cops are going to have to leave you alone, none of this stopping your car shit and taking your weed. If you’re going to fine people on the way back then fine people and let them go, fine payment records sealed if not destroyed.

    Yeah! People will be bringing it back with them, like back here to The Big Apple! De Blasio needs to legalize in NYC. No two ways about it.

    I want to see some millionaires rise up from the cannabis industry on the East Coast. You have to do it this way to keep the cannabis rags to riches and jobs drumbeat, and to wrest the market from the Mexican cartels. I want that freakin money to stay in the States!

  12. HB 2165 to Repeal Marijuana Prohibition was just introduced by Republican David Simpson. Texans please write and call your Congressman, or click on the Take Action link as soon as a link to 2165 is made available. With eachother’s help, Prohibition will end even in the most unlikely places.

    [Paul Armentano responds: You will find the Take Action link for HB 2165 here:

  13. @Oracle;
    All “that money” does stay in the states. Whose banks do you think have been laundering all the drug money all these years? U.S. Banks. ( Brittains’ HSBC is just a drop in the bucket). Now all that money can be laundered through campaign funds so it makes U.S. elections more predictable, doesn’t it?

    Now if you mean keep it here in the US LEGALLY, WELL… That opens a different door…

    Mexico, and Jamaica for that matter will be great allies for us in the long run as far as providing non Genetically Engineered crops, pesticide and herbicide free. U.S. Demand for these healthy commodities will help shape standards in competitive foreign markets where we have failed to regulate domestically, (regardless of prohibition).
    As the cartels undergo a reduction in revenue, and legitimate companies replace them, Mexico happens to have more regulations that prohibit genetically engineered crops in order to protect native strains than we do in the U.S…. But with a failed Cartel government they cannot be enforced. Post-prohibition, We will need to work with increasing cooperation with the Mexican and Canadian governments to ensure that wholesale imports of cannabis meet the market standards we fail to enforce with corporations here in the U.S.: We can’t even get genetically engineered ingredients labeled here in the U.S. Fortunately, there are strains of cannabis that become a source of national pride, and within a regulated market, these strains will be competitively advertised not simply for their cheap availability, but for their high supply in clean, natural quality.
    I for one, can’t wait to see what legally regulated cannabis will do to a Mexican economy with subsidized medicine and education, a paradigm shift to help rural indigenous people that would not have been possible without Americans uniting to end prohibition in their own lands first.

  14. This is not really a bad situation at all. People need to get their hands in the soil and learn how to garden. Six plants can keep the whole neighborhood smoked up, just use BIG pots, lots of light, and give them room to grow sideways as well as up.

  15. It will be interesting to see how law enforcement handles driving under the influence, with these new laws passed. DUI laws pose strict consequences for anyone who is drinking and driving. In Arizona, for example, a first time DUI with a BAC between .08-.15 can result in 6 months jail time and up to 5 years probation, along with additional fines. Although DC’s DUI laws are different, I wonder how drinking impairment laws will differ from marijuana impairment.

  16. Just legalize it! That’s enough of the legislation. Let’s see how fast we can get this (Washington, D.C. concept)of legalization on the national ballot for the voters to decide. Three cheers for Mayor Bowser of D.C. “We the people wish we had more good politicians like Mayor Bowser that cares about what “We the People” vote for!!!
    I think the courts and President Obama should just go ahead and save time by going ahead and nationally televising that cannabis is no longer illegal, that no more tax dollars will be wasted on this foolish, greedy victimization of the fine American citizens that deserve to have this natural medicine without ANY MORE HASSELES fro the government. No selling, but you can grow your own if you wish and if a friend, neighbor is in need of some good natural medicine or herbals, then we the people are hereby granted full right to give away freely to someone in need for no compensation. This will stop those cartels dead in their tracks!!! No more government sponsored drug dealing police protected informants on every street corner. And no more of government creating prisoners, stealing pride and building prisons to house victims of government pre-meditated crimes.

  17. In Arizona, for example, a first time DUI with a BAC between .08-.15 can result in 6 months jail time and up to 5 years probation, along with additional fines.

    Although DC’s DUI laws are different, I wonder how drinking impairment laws will differ from marijuana impairment. – Katie

    The same tests and penalties should apply…because alcohol and marijuana cause the same perceptual and physical effects on the human brain and it’s assistant body.

    I can’t understand why every one can’t understand that cannabis causes people to overestimate their abilities and has an anesthetic effect on the human brain and its assistant body…or is that alcohol?

    Anyhow, It’s important to arrest every one for something or another!

    America can arrest itself out of almost everything…until the Country itself is a Prison?

  18. Will legalization make LEO return all the ceased property? Will the theft of property without due process end? Will the war on the american people end and the prison industrial complex be exposed for what it really is? How many more people will be forced to go through the retraining and reeducation of incarceration due to policing for profit?

  19. “If the Republican Congress, which can’t decide how to keep open one of its premier security agencies, the Department of Homeland Security, wants to pick a fight with the District over our local marijuana reform law, a fight is what they will get,” said Norton.

    “Pot is de facto legal among young people, except for people of color here and around the country.

    The people of the District of Columbia voted overwhelmingly for Initiative 71 when they learned that virtually only people of color end up with drug arrests for possession of marijuana.

    It is well worth a fight to retain a local law with racial justice as its centerpiece.”- Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton (D-DC )

  20. The police would just find another way to illegally search your car. They will be shining flashlights in our eyes, to see if they are bloodshot. Even though many of us are responsible, there are far too many teenagers and young adults that aren’t. It’s a step in the right direction though. I just wish to these states would follow Colorado’s lead. And I have my fingers crossed for the new Pennsylvania legislation.

  21. I wish all states have what D.C. now enjoys.I’m in MD and can’t get medical cannabis though laws are in place, another year of maybe is not good enough. The Democrat’s run this state but deliver nothing for their support! at least if the GOP backs it I’ll get better than lip service.
    No I don’t approve of A.Harris or any prohibitionist.

Leave a Reply